State Strategies to Promote Angel Investment for Economic Growth

The following is a summary of an  "Issue Brief" by the NGA ("National Governor's Association") Center for Best Practices in Washington, DC entitled, State Strategies to Promote Angel Investment for Economic Growth. The report  pointed to strategies that states should use to promote Angel Investment for economic growth.
 
The report stated that Governors are increasingly interested in entrepreneurship because of its key role in driving business innovation. While entrepreneurs face several common challenges, including developing business acumen and making connections with experts and mentors, often their greatest challenge is raising capital. Entrepreneurs’ emerging technologies are frequently viewed as too risky for banks, private equity firms and venture capitalists and yet many fledgling companies require more investment to grow than can be raised from friends and family. Angel investors are increasingly stepping in to fill this gap.
 
Angel investors are wealthy individuals with business or technology backgrounds who provide entrepreneurs with capital, connections, and guidance. They provide early-stage financing in a space once occupied by venture capitalists, who now invest primarily in larger deals and more mature companies. Angels invest in local and regional ventures, primarily in high-technology sectors, giving their investments local impact. In the past decade, many angel investors have formed and joined groups because investing through groups offers several advantages, most notably a large and more diverse portfolio, access to expertise, and higher deal flow.
 
States increasingly recognize the value of angel investments and are adopting policies to promote them. Some have created statewide networks to assist the formation of angel groups, link angel groups to share best practices, and help groups invest together in companies that need more funding than a single group can offer.
 
Governors have several options to encourage the formation of angel groups to expand early-stage investment:
 
Promote seminars on private equity investment for current and potential angel investors;
Assist entrepreneurs by connecting them with existing entrepreneurship education and        services;
Facilitate the formation of statewide angel groups to organize and empower local leadership and build investor knowledge;
Ensure that angel investors are well-represented on state economic development advisory boards, along with entrepreneurs, universities, and other industry representatives; and
Identify and collect metrics to monitor the impact on policies to encourage angel investment.
 
Clayton White.

Angels: 2010 Will See Exits & Opportunities

2010 will bring more promising investment opportunities for angel investors and will feature more exits than any year in the past decade. That’s the conclusion of a panel discussion at the Always On Venture Summitin Menlo Park, Calif. featuring several prominent angels and veteran investors. The panel suggested that there will likely be 50 or more initial public offerings in 2010, making it a banner year for start-ups and their financial backers. 

 
The panel also suggested that public technology companies will start acquiring smaller companies again in the interest of staying competitive. With Google’s recent acquisition of AdMob Inc., a mobile ad network, for $750 million in stock, other media companies are realizing that they will have to acquire innovation to keep up.
 
Other panelists said promising new industry segments are emerging. With the proliferation of social media and government spending on healthcare software and cleantech, angel investors will have ample opportunities in emerging business areas.
 
Investors will be looking for start-ups that can go a long way on a small budget. For cleantech that means a focus on material sciences, software and thermoelectrics. Other panelists said new communications platforms like Twitter have sparked a revolution of real-time content sharing that will spawn hundreds of new companies and provide lucrative returns.
 
The conclusion was that 2010 will be a time of opportunity for angels.
 
 

The Growth of Angel Investment

 Angel groups have grown significantly in the last decade, as more and more organizations have been established and more individual angels have joined the groups. Angel groups now exist in nearly every American state and Canadian province. In May of 2008, the Angel Capital Association listed 165 members. Recently the Angel Capital Education Foundation listed 281 Angel groups in 49 US states and Canada. The only state not represented was Louisiana. That number is now 282 with the addition of South Coast Angel Fund, which now represents Louisiana on that list.

The term “angel” originated in the early 1900s and referred to investors who made risky investments to support Broadway theatrical productions. Today, the term “angel” refers to high-net worth individuals, or “accredited investors,” who typically invest in and support start-up companies in their early stages of growth.

Angel groups offer accredited angel investors the opportunity to invest in and help build successful companies – while also having a good time. Every group is different in terms of investment strategy and culture, but Angel groups offer interested investors a variety of benefits such as:
 
1. An expectation of a significant return on their investment. 
2. A disciplined approach to investing imposed by a both the due diligence process and the diversity of expertise provided by a group of members with various backgrounds.
3. Lower risks by diversification of investments.
4. Social benefits in meeting and working with other successful individuals. Participation in the screening, due diligence or monitoring teams is an enjoyable, educational and rewarding experience.
5. A strong sense of satisfaction from aiding and mentoring entrepreneurs.
6. Investments Louisiana businesses may qualify for Louisiana Tax Credits such as the Digital Interactive Media Credits and other Louisiana incentive programs.
 

Venture Capital and Louisiana's Digital Interactive Media Incentives Program

The Wall Street Journal on Monday July 6, 2009 had a Page C-1 story entitled, Venture-Backed Start-Ups Seek Stimulus. The gist of the story was that venture funds like Novak Biddle Venture Partners, RockPort Capital Partners and Flywheel Ventures were directing the start-ups they are investing in to explore the federal stimulus package as a means of finding additional capital.

This story suggests to me that venture capital funds and angel investors would find Louisiana's new digital interactive media tax credit incentive program very attractive. Marketable tax credits are not much different in economic terms than stimulus program grants. A start-up developing a web platform, mobile application or software package can get marketable tax credits equal to 35% of the funds they spend in Louisiana on labor residing in the state and 25% of all other expenditures.

If, for example, a start-up used labor residing in Louisiana to develop a new web platform and in the process spent $1,000,000 in Louisiana. The State of Louisiana would issue tax credits for $350,000 and the start-up could sell the tax credits for $0.85 to $0.90 on the dollar realizing perhaps a little more than $300,000 in extra funds. Thus, a venture capital fund investment of $1,000,000 spent on labor residing in Louisiana becomes an investment of $1,300,000.  That seems like stimulus that a venture capital fund or an angel investor would like to see.

Erich P Rapp.